Protection
Method |
Strengths |
Weaknesses |
Paint
or Coating |
Easy
to apply, inexpensive |
Short
life, easily damaged, corrosion at coating damage |
Grease
or Wax |
Inexpensive |
Time
consuming application, absorbs corrosion |
Corrosion
Resistant Alloys |
Excellent
protection when properly selected |
Expensive,
rapid failure with improper material selection |
Electroplating
(Cd, Zn, Zn-Ni) |
Inexpensive,
readily available |
Easily
damaged, corrosion at coating damage |
Hot
Dip Galvanizing |
Good
long term protection, readily available |
Multiple
make-up and break out very difficult |
Fluoropolymer
Coating |
Low
make-up and break out torque |
Easily
damaged, corrosion at coating damage |
Many industrial complex managers take fastener corrosion for
granted, including expensive change out of weakened systems
that become corroded. Several alternative systems have been
used in industry to address fastener corrosion as follows:
Paint
or Coating
Painting
or coating fasteners is an inexpensive protection method,
both for installation and use. This method of protection is
easily damaged or can simply wear away with time. Corrosion
readily occurs at sites of coating damage from normal make-up
procedures.
Grease
or Wax
Coating
fasteners with grease or wax is an inexpensive protection
method, but it is also time consuming and messy. Any areas
left unprotected can easily corrode. Grease can allow moisture
penetration and accumulation of dust, dirt, or other impurities
in the grease resulting in corrosion. Grease can also absorb
corrosive gases such as SO2, CO2, H2S, that can accelerate
corrosion of steel nuts and bolts.
Corrosion
Resistant Alloys (CRA)
Properly
selected, corrosion resistant alloys provide excellent corrosion
protection, but selection of the wrong alloy can result in
rapid failure. Corrosion of an improperly selected CRA can
occur as crevice corrosion, pitting, dealloying, chloride
stress corrosion cracking or hydrogen cracking. Galvanic corrosion
can be a problem if the fastener is used with a more noble
base metal or an active metal such as aluminum alloys. This
is the most expensive protection method.
Electroplating
(Cd, Zn, Zn-Ni)
Electroplating
offers minimal corrosion protection with added cost. At elevated
temperatures, liquid metal embrittlement and hydrogen embrittlement
can be a problem. Corrosion readily occurs at sites of coating
damage from normal make-up procedures.
Hot
Dip Galvanizing
Hot dip
galvanizing offers good, long term corrosion protection with
added cost. The galvanized surface is rough, and nuts for
galvanizing must be tapped over-size to allow proper make-up.
The high coefficient of friction due to the surface roughness
make multiple make-up and break out very difficult.
Fluoropolymer
Coating
Fluoropolymer
coating systems, e.g., Teflon, are very effective in reducing
make-up and break out torque. Because of limited coating thickness,
i.e., <1.5 mils (38 µm), corrosion protection is
limited. Corrosion occurs at sites of coating damage that
results during normal make-up procedures.
|